I’ve just been perusing this article over at Engadget. The premise is nice and simple: if you had your way, how would you change the Wii? There’s been a fair few comments and most of them simply reaffirm my position that people are idiots. I’ll get onto that in a bit.
Before we go any further, let me nail my colours to the mast: I’m a complete Nintendo fanboy geek. I love my Wii, I love my DS Lite and I love Mario in a purely platonic way. That said, Mario Kart on the Gamecube was responsible for the single most upsetting moment in my life as a gamer*. So, given my credentials to provide an objective criticism of other people’s opinions (ok, ok, I’m going to be about as objective as Michael Moore talking about gun control. It’s just that I have more charisma, less fat and a lot less money) here are some of the most common gripes about the Wii on the Engadget piece along with my highly qualified response:
“The Wii should also play DVD’s”
Oh snap! I’d forgotten that it was 1997 and all DVD players cost over £1000! Come on you idiot – who actually needs another DVD player? According to the DVD Entertinment Group (who appear to be some sort of industry body for consumer electronics manufacturers, movie studios and so on), more that 80% of US households were estimated to have at least 1 DVD player by the end of 2005 [clicky]. By the end of 2006 they were estimating that 55% of DVD owners already have more than 1 player [clicky clicky].
“The Wii should do HDTV quality graphics”
Yes, that would be lovely. It would also be a prohibitive factor in allowing the Wii to be sold at such a competitive price, which is a major reason in it’s success to date.
“The Wii should have a wired network socket as well as wireless”
You mean some people don’t have wireless? How the hell do they cope? It’s like going back to dial-up after using broadband for 5 years. Ok I’m being a bit of a dick about that one, but I don’t think it’s unreasonable to assume that a decent percentage of people with broadband these days also have wireless.
“The Wii should have rechargeable Wiimotes”
Actually I agree with this one. I bought a Joytech charger pack from Amazon and it’s saved me a small fortune in AA batteries. That said, I do like the fact that it takes standard batteries so you don’t have to buy a brand new remote if the battery dies like you would have to with the PS3 or the XBox 360.
“The Wii should make it easier to connect with your friends online”
I agree with this one as well. The “friend code” solution that Nintendo use for the DS and the Wii feels clumsy and is the single biggest failing of both systems. I can see the board room discussions now:
“How can we protect our younger gamers online?”
“Why don’t we require them to exchange 16-digit numbers with one another before they can connect?”
“Genius! Nobody can remember a 16-digit number. The children are saved!”
The XBox Live Gamertag is by far a more elegant solution, plus it allows you to handle your contacts in one, central place, instead of on a game-by-game basis. Parental controls could still be placed on the ability to add or accept new friends if required.
So there you have it: the Wii isn’t perfect and only a percentage of the people making comments were idiots (~93%?). Sorry if anyone feels the need to shoot themselves after reading through this – I should really start putting some sort of geekometer measurement at the start of my posts.
*Bootnote: Actually I’ve exaggerated that slightly. Mairi was entirely responsible for the single most upsetting moment in my life as a gamer, but Mario Kart was the delivery mechanism. The elation of finding myself in 1st place on the final straight of the final lap on Peach Beach quickly turned sour when, about a second from the finish line, Mairi hit me with a shell and then knocked me sideways so that I was stuck behind the finishing line pole. She stole 1st place, while I could only manage 7th by the time I’d reversed off the pole and over the line. I actually almost cried because of the shock and trauma I was suffering from. Not to mention the fact that Mairi was cackling with glee next to me for the next 5 minutes. In hindsight, it’s no great surprise that we’re not going out any more